Adapter Parity Matrix
Implementation status of field types across 11 adapter packages. All adapters support 27 of 31 types.
Legend
- Y -- Native UI library component
- FB -- HTML fallback (semantic HTML, data-* attributes, ARIA)
- --- -- Not implemented
Matrix
| # | Type Key | fluent | mui | headless | antd | chakra | mantine | atlaskit | base-web | heroui | radix | react-aria |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 (Core) | ||||||||||||
| 1 | Textbox | Y | Y | FB | Y | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | Y |
| 2 | Number | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | Y |
| 3 | Toggle | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | Y |
| 4 | Dropdown | Y | Y | FB | Y | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | Y |
| 6 | MultiSelect | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | | 7 | DateControl | Y | Y | FB | Y | Y | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 8 | Slider | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | Y | | 9 | RadioGroup | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | Y | | 10 | CheckboxGroup | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | Y | | 11 | Textarea | Y | Y | FB | Y | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | | 12 | DynamicFragment | Y | Y | FB | Y | Y | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 13 | ReadOnly | Y | Y | FB | Y | Y | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | | Tier 2 (Extended) | | | | | | | | | | | | | 14 | Rating | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 15 | Autocomplete | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | Y | | 16 | DateTime | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 17 | DateRange | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 18 | PhoneInput | Y | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 19 | FileUpload | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB | | 20 | ColorPicker | Y | Y | FB | Y | FB | Y | FB | FB | FB | FB | FB |
Notes:
- fluent and mui use framework-native components for all fields.
- headless uses semantic HTML for all fields (this IS its native implementation).
- antd uses native Ant Design v5 components; 6 Chakra fields use HTML fallbacks due to Ark UI DTS issues.
- radix uses 6 native Radix UI primitives + semantic HTML (primitives-first, unstyled).
- react-aria uses 10 native React Aria Components + semantic HTML (accessibility-first).
- shadcn/ui: No dedicated package. Use @formosaic/radix as a base with local Tailwind/shadcn wrappers.
Adapter Strength Summary
Full coverage (27 field types): All 11 adapters implement 27 field types (13 Tier 1 + 10 Tier 2 extended + 5 read-only variants).
Native Tier 2 implementations:
- antd -- 6 native: Rate, AutoComplete, DatePicker+showTime, RangePicker, Upload, ColorPicker
- mantine -- 5 native: Rating, Autocomplete, DateTimePicker, FileInput, ColorInput
- react-aria -- 1 native: ComboBox for Autocomplete